When homeowners discover faulty workmanship in their newly constructed or renovated properties, navigating the legal landscape can be overwhelming. One of the biggest concerns is whether they can recover attorney fees when pursuing claims against contractors.
In Colorado, the rules regarding attorney fees in construction defect cases are complex and nuanced. Understanding these rules is essential for homeowners seeking fair compensation for their losses.
The "American Rule" and Its Impact
In the United States, the default rule regarding attorney fees is known as the "American Rule." Under this rule, each party pays their own attorney fees, regardless of who wins the case.
This means that unless there is a specific contractual provision or a statute that allows for fee recovery, homeowners typically cannot recover attorney fees from the opposing party. In construction defect claims, this rule can make recovering attorney fees challenging.
However, there are important exceptions that Colorado homeowners should understand.
The Colorado Consumer Protection Act
One of the most powerful tools for recovering attorney fees is the Colorado Consumer Protection Act (CCPA). This act provides significant protection for homeowners dealing with construction defects.
How the CCPA Helps with Attorney Fees
The CCPA allows prevailing parties to recover reasonable attorney fees and costs in actions brought under the act. If a homeowner successfully proves that a contractor engaged in deceptive trade practices or other violations covered by the CCPA, they may be entitled to have their attorney fees paid by the opposing party.
This makes the CCPA an attractive option for homeowners pursuing construction defect claims. For more information about how consumer fraud laws apply to construction, see our guide on consumer fraud in Colorado construction.
Prevailing Party Clauses in Construction Contracts
Another avenue for attorney fee recovery involves contractual provisions. Homeowners should carefully review their construction contracts to look for prevailing party clauses.
What Is a Prevailing Party Clause?
A prevailing party clause is a contractual provision that allows the winning party in a legal dispute to recover attorney fees and costs from the losing party. If such a clause exists in your construction contract, it can significantly impact your ability to recover attorney fees.
Why Contract Review Matters
This underscores the importance of thorough contract review before signing. Understanding your rights and obligations regarding attorney fees under any prevailing party clauses can be crucial to the outcome of a construction defect dispute.
For guidance on what to look for in construction contracts, read our article on understanding construction contracts.
Understanding Attorney Fees vs. Costs
It's important to distinguish between attorney fees and costs, as they are treated differently under Colorado law.
Attorney Fees
Attorney fees refer to the fees charged by legal counsel for their services.
Recoverable Costs
Costs encompass a broader range of expenses incurred during the legal process. In Colorado, certain costs associated with pursuing a construction defect claim may be recoverable even if attorney fees are not.
What Costs Can Be Recovered
While attorney fees may not always be recoverable, homeowners may still be able to recover certain costs associated with their case under C.R.S. 13-16-111.
These recoverable costs can include:
Filing fees
Deposition fees
Expert witness fees
Other expenses directly related to the litigation process
It's crucial for homeowners to keep detailed records of these costs and ensure they are properly documented for potential reimbursement. Learn more about expert witnesses in construction defect cases.
Working with an Experienced Colorado Construction Defect Lawyer
Given the complexities of construction defect claims and the legal framework surrounding attorney fees and costs, seeking guidance from an experienced attorney is highly advisable.
How a Lawyer Can Help
A knowledgeable construction defect lawyer can:
Assess the merits of your case
Advise you on your rights under the CCPA and other relevant statutes
Help you navigate the legal process effectively
Review your contracts for prevailing party clauses
For more information about the costs involved, see our guide on construction defect lawyer costs in Colorado.
Key Takeaways
Recovering attorney fees for pursuing claims against contractors in Colorado is not guaranteed under the default "American Rule." However, homeowners do have options for seeking reimbursement for their legal expenses.
The most promising avenues include:
The Colorado Consumer Protection Act
Prevailing party clauses in construction contracts
Recovery of certain litigation costs even when attorney fees aren't available
By understanding these nuances and working with skilled legal representation, homeowners can better position themselves to pursue fair compensation for construction defects.
If you're facing construction defects in your home, consider consulting with a construction defect attorney to understand your options and rights under Colorado law.
Have Questions About Construction Defects?
Our experienced construction defect attorneys are here to help. Schedule a free 15-minute screening call to discuss your situation.
